Is It Worth Refinancing? How to Work Out If It Pays Off
By Fay
"Should I refinance?" is one of the questions I'm asked most. The honest answer is: it depends on the numbers. A lower rate sounds like an easy win, but switching costs, your loan term and the features you need all affect whether you actually come out ahead.
Here's how to work it out properly. If you'd like the basics first, what refinancing is and the signs it's worth looking into, start with my Refinancing 101 guide at themortgagemum.com.au.
Step 1: Compare your rate with what you could get
Start by finding your current interest rate, which is on your latest loan statement or in your banking app. Then compare it with what lenders are offering borrowers like you today.
When comparing, look at the comparison rate, not just the headline rate. The comparison rate includes most fees and charges, so it gives you a truer picture of the cost of a loan.
Step 2: Work out what switching will cost
Typical refinancing costs include:
• A discharge fee from your current lender
• Government fees to register and discharge the mortgage, which vary by state
• Application, valuation or settlement fees with the new lender, which some lenders waive
• Break costs if you're on a fixed rate and leave before the fixed term ends. These can be large, so always check first.
• Lenders Mortgage Insurance (LMI) if you borrow more than 80% of your property's value with the new lender. This can wipe out the savings, so it's important to check.
Step 3: Find your break-even point
Your break-even point is how long it takes for the savings to cover the switching costs. The simple formula is:
Switching costs ÷ monthly saving = months to break even
A worked example
The rates below are illustrative only. They aren't current rates or an offer of credit, and the example uses principal and interest repayments.
Say you owe $600,000 with 25 years left on your loan:
• At 6.50%, your repayments are about $4,051 a month.
• Refinance to 5.90%, keeping the same 25 years, and they drop to about $3,829 a month.
• That's a saving of around $222 a month, or roughly $2,660 a year.
• If switching costs $1,200, you'd break even in about 6 months.
• Over the full 25 years, you'd pay around $66,000 less interest.
In this example, refinancing clearly pays off. But if switching costs were much higher, or you planned to sell within a few months, the answer could be different.
Step 4: Watch out for the 30-year reset trap
This is the mistake I see most often. When you refinance, it's easy to take out a new 30-year loan, which makes your repayments look much lower.
Using the same example, refinancing that $600,000 to 5.90% over a fresh 30 years drops repayments to about $3,559 a month. That looks like a saving of nearly $500 a month. But because you've added five extra years, you'd pay around $681,000 in total interest, roughly $66,000 more than if you'd stayed on your old loan at the higher rate.
The fix is simple: keep your loan term the same, or shorter, when you refinance. Or, if you take a longer term for breathing room, keep paying your old repayment amount if you can.
Step 5: Look beyond the rate
Sometimes refinancing is worth it even when the rate saving is small, because of what else you get:
• An offset account, which can reduce the interest you pay on your savings balance
• A fixed and variable split, for a mix of certainty and flexibility
• Access to equity for renovations or an investment property
• Consolidating debts, though rolling short-term debts into a 30-year loan can mean paying more in total, so we'll always check the full cost
• A move to Shariah-compliant finance, if you'd prefer to move away from interest-based lending. Learn more about Shariah finance.
Beware of cashback offers
Cashback deals can be tempting, but a few thousand dollars upfront can be outweighed by a higher rate or fees over the life of the loan. Always compare the total cost, not just the cashback.
When refinancing might not be worth it
• You're on a fixed rate with high break costs and only a short time left. It may be better to wait until the fixed term ends.
• You'd have to pay LMI because your equity is below 20%.
• You're planning to sell soon, before you'd reach break-even.
• Your finances have changed in a way that makes it harder to qualify, such as a drop in income or new debts.
• Your current lender will match the rate. Sometimes asking your lender for a better deal is the easiest win of all.
A quick checklist
1. Find your current rate and loan balance.
2. Compare comparison rates for your situation today.
3. Add up the switching costs, including any break costs or LMI.
4. Work out your break-even point.
5. Keep your loan term the same or shorter.
6. Check the features you need, not just the rate.
Let's run your numbers
If you haven't reviewed your home loan in a while, I'd be happy to take a look. I'll compare options from a wide panel of lenders, work out your real savings after costs, and tell you honestly if staying put is the better choice. I help homeowners across Western Sydney, Brisbane, Melbourne and Australia-wide.
Learn more about refinancing, compare repayments with the Loan Repayment Calculator at themortgagemum.com.au, or book a chat. There's no obligation.
This article is general information only and doesn't take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. It isn't tax, legal or financial product advice. The examples are illustrative only and don't reflect current interest rates. Fees, rates and lending policies vary between lenders and change over time, and all loans are subject to lender approval, terms, conditions and fees. Please seek advice specific to your situation before making any decisions.
Originally published at themortgagemum.com.au
Fay Elhaj (CRN 572248) and Haj-Rank Pty Ltd T/A The Mortgage Mum ABN 56 688 902 258 (CRN 572249) are credit representatives of Purple Circle Financial Services Pty Ltd ABN 21 611 305 170, Australian Credit Licence Number 486112.